If you ever seem to be a sitcom fan and The Big Bang Theory is your favorite because of the lead, Sheldon Cooper (Jim Parsons); I'm sure you'll be able to relate to this article. Dear readers, today I'm going to talk about The Closure Alternative (Big Bang Season 6- Episode 21) and my inputs on this morbid obsession with closure.
The most amazing writers end their books abruptly; like you're reading and there seems to be no conclusion for what would have happened to the characters? Did they really meet, survive or die? Sometimes we even miss out the chance to know what the author might have thought about the end of the story. With reading, we get more attached to the characters. Somehow, we seem to get more worried when the fictional character is facing a problem and with them, we weave our own version of the story.
People say it's hard to make a movie which is as close as it has been described in the book. Well, I couldn't disagree more because every reader makes his/her own character sketch and it isn't an easy task to put all those sketches in one single character in the movie. However, it's just not books but even movies end abruptly. What is the motive behind this? Why do they make us scratch our heads or leave us in a profound state of curiosity?
Linking it back to my favorite character, Sheldon Cooper (So he's this scientist guy who has his own set of annoying idiosyncrasies. He lives with his roommate Leonard, who has to bear all his tantrums. Sheldon has an obsessive compulsive disorder and the episode I mentioned, he faces a problem where he cannot accept situations which have no closure; like not being able to blow all the candles on a birthday cake, not completing a word in a sentence or not finishing the tic tac toe, not letting the dominos trip, etc.) he goes through the same problem some of us do.
We get really obsessive about characters and it becomes difficult to watch a movie or read a book with no closure. Recently, I read one of the most beautiful books, The fault in our stars by John Green whose character Hazel Grace goes through the same obsession; so much that she writes fan mails and even goes all the way to Amsterdam just to meet the author and get all her answers.
It's not like people obsessed with closure are facing a psychological threat but somehow, reading takes us to another world. It's a magical palace with a thousand imaginary worlds, of our own. Movies, adapted from books play the same trick. For some, reading might just be a hobby but some really wish to crawl in those books and be a part of it. Like how would it feel to be there with Harry Potter fighting his fight against Lord Voldemort, to get lost in the labyrinth with Alice in Wonderland or to be the Charlie and take a tour in Willy Wonka's chocolate factory!
We've had several movies which end unanticipated and the people who seem to appreciate this style had something else to say. So I asked a friend of mine, Niraj Mulani, to tell me what he felt about closure and he said, 'I think I like it when the author or director leaves the story on a lose end and let's the audience figure out what might have happened because then it let's me be a part of the story and the audience can have their own version as the suspense.' So the director or author plays safe with not disappointing the audience and as well have their own happy ending.
The truth is we don't really like unfinished things and this closure, we're forgetting how closely it affects us. For years, we've tried to give ourselves the comfort to deal with all the discomforts we find. Dealing with deaths isn't easy, so we came up with funerals as a closure to the dead and the sentiments attached with them. When incongruency took over us, we came up with the comfort of defense mechanisms which could as well be a closure for someone ignoring reality. We need closures in life, to deal with situations, people, relationships and deaths; to realize that something is over and we need to let go maybe because our mind is still stuck in the things we didn't conclude. We need to move past it and realize that no matter how hard it hurt, it's time to take a step ahead then moving backwards. Closure is a healing we all need; those last words said and the last goodbyes- we can't be devoid of the last chance. The closure may or may not meet your expectations but we all seek it to let the old go and say hello to new things.
That reminds me of how Yann Mattel beautifully put it in Life of Pi, 'It's important in life to conclude things properly. Only then can you let go.'
That reminds me of how Yann Mattel beautifully put it in Life of Pi, 'It's important in life to conclude things properly. Only then can you let go.'
Deep thought..awesomely written...:-)
ReplyDeleteSuperbly written priyu...
ReplyDeleteSo true about how we all need some closure in life !
ReplyDeleteVery well written :)
Very true... Life is about accepting the unexpected and moving ahaead...well put
ReplyDeleteThank you so much everyone :)
ReplyDelete(y) good work
ReplyDeleteSomewhere deep inside we have this mind set to have a happy ending, blame it on the Indian cinema or the never ending Indian TV shows, where you know if its not the happy ending its not the end. Closures are good, gives you N.. number of endings instead of one.
ReplyDeleteVery nicely stated your views on the closure
ReplyDeleteWell you could have used the example of return of Sherlock Holmes and how it created the whole world to conclude what actually happened..
@ Aayush: We can blatantly blame it to Disney movies or Bollywood flicks for hoping for a happy ending but somehow, we need to accept that life can't be fair all the time.
ReplyDeleteI'm glad you could understand what I had to convey :)
@ Mohit: I felt I should add Sherlock in my conclusion but to be honest, there seems to be no closure towards my Benediction towards him.
ReplyDeleteThough it shall remain a fact that even after watching the ones we love die in front of us, we still hope for a closure or might as well weave a fallacy of them coming back to life. I could add it on my new post, Repercussions of not having a closure! :p
Anyways, thank you so much :)
bonjour priyanka!!long time..u write well!really do!
ReplyDeleteThank you so much Pratik! :)
ReplyDeleteVery well written!
ReplyDeleteLoved it...
ReplyDeletewww.youtube.com/watch?v=ZV2knGdIJNI
ReplyDelete